How consistent and comprehensive are the author’s conclusions with the reported results?
Han, K., & Mithas, S. (2013). Information technology outsourcing and non-IT operating costs: An empirical investigation. MIS Quarterly,37(1), 315-331.
Write a summary essay about the article you read.
The summary must be written in your own words and it must be complete. You may use quotes from the article very sparingly (I don’t want to see an entire paragraph in groups or even ½ of a paragraph in quotes). Whenever you read a scientific article you should consider the validity of the article. This is usually done by evaluating the material and by asking a number of questions about the article. When evaluating an article you should always consider the source of the information presented, the presentation of the information, and the validity of the article. Please summarize the article by addressing some of the following aspects.
A. Theoretical Perspective(about 100 words)
Critique the author’s conceptual framework.
Comment on the need for this study and its importance.
How effectively does the author tie the study to relevant theory and prior research?
Evaluate the clarity and appropriateness of the research questions or hypotheses if any.
B. Research Design and Analysis (about 150 words)
Critique the appropriateness and adequacy of the study’s design about the research questions or hypotheses if any.
Critique the appropriateness and quality (e.g., reliability, validity) of the measures used if any.
Critique the adequacy of the study’s data analyses if any. For example: Have critical statistical assumptions been met? Are the analyses appropriate for the study’s design? Are the analyses appropriate for the data collected?
C. Interpretation and Implications of Results (about 100 words)
Critique the author’s discussion of the methodological and/or conceptual limitations of the results.
How consistent and comprehensive are the author’s conclusions with the reported results?
How well did the author relate the results to the study’s theoretical base if any?
In your view, what is the significance of the study, and what are its primary implications for theory, future research, and practice?
